MODLR and Pigment both support financial and operational planning. They differ in how models are structured, how reporting, automation and AI are delivered, and what each takes to implement, own and run over three to five years.
MODLR
Pigment
Pigment is an integrated business planning platform that extends from finance into workforce, sales and supply chain planning. MODLR is built around flexible multidimensional cubes and tools that trained finance and business users can manage.
Trained finance and business users can manage planning models and processes according to their permissions and the solution designed for their business, with IT, vendor or partner support where particular tasks call for it.
Cubes organise financial and operational data by entity, product, customer, department, scenario and time, and cube formulas connect calculations within and between cubes.
The Visual Process Editor and Visual Scripting Engine provide building blocks for database queries, API requests, files, transformations and model updates, combined into workflows that prepare and load data.
Workviews support detailed reporting and analysis, while Cards provide dashboards and interactive interfaces. Both use the same underlying model data.
Multi-currency processing, intercompany matching and eliminations, validation, audit reporting and consolidated financial reporting sit in MODLR’s Financial Close and Consolidation solution.
Each customer has a separate single-tenant cloud instance, with computing capacity that can be increased or reduced to suit the workload.
A summary of selected tools before each decision area is examined in detail. It is not a performance ranking or an exhaustive feature inventory.
| Criterion | MODLR | Pigment |
|---|---|---|
| Model structures | Cubes, dimensions and hierarchies | Lists, Metrics and Tables |
| Reporting tools | Workviews for detailed analysis, with Cards for dashboards and interactive interfaces | Boards that display grids, KPIs and charts from application data |
| Scenarios | A Scenario dimension can organise actuals, budgets, forecasts and alternative plans for comparison | Versions and Scenarios support alternative assumptions and comparisons within planning applications |
| Data processes | Integration tools and a Visual Process Editor for connecting, transforming and loading data and updating models | Connectors, scheduled imports and APIs for moving data into and out of planning applications |
| Excel | Excel Add-in for reporting and working with model data from spreadsheets | Pigment Connector for Excel retrieves data from views and sends spreadsheet data into Pigment |
| Automation and workflow | Visual processes for importing data, updating models and handling errors | Automations trigger notifications and tasks from Metric conditions; linked workflows are available for Enterprise customers |
| AI | Natural-language data queries, model exploration, scriptable-process assistance and Workview editing in the first release, with access being rolled out | Analyst and Modeler agents, plus a Consolidation Agent; the Planner Agent was marked as coming soon at the 4 October 2026 review |
| Governance | User management and security controls, with validation rules and audit reporting in Financial Close and Consolidation | Separate permissions and data-access rights, combined into roles |
| Consolidation | Financial Close and Consolidation with data loading, reconciliation, validation and audit reporting | Multi-entity, multi-currency consolidation with intercompany matching and eliminations, journals and reporting |
| Scalability | Resizable single-tenant cloud instances | Elastic processing engine with parallel processing |
| Implementation and costs | Scope, timetable, responsibilities and costs are set through a tailored proposal | Scope, timetable, responsibilities and costs are set through a tailored proposal |
| Key consideration | How the cube-based model fits your team’s skills and ownership model | How Lists, Metrics and Tables represent your business and connect across applications |
Both platforms cover the core of financial and operational planning. The differences sit mostly in how each capability is delivered and packaged, so confirm the detail for your own subscription.
| Capability | MODLR | Pigment |
|---|---|---|
| Multidimensional planning models |
|
|
| Scenario planning and what-if analysis |
|
|
| Multi-entity, multi-currency consolidation |
|
|
| Role-based permissions and audit trails |
|
|
| Planning beyond finance |
Financial and operational models in one environment
|
Extends into sales, workforce, supply chain and operational planning
|
| Excel connectivity |
Excel Add-in
|
Connector for Excel, provided as an Office Add-in
|
| Scheduled data imports and APIs |
|
|
| Process automation for data and model updates |
Visual Process Editor
|
Scheduled imports and Automations for notifications and tasks; linked workflows are for Enterprise customers
|
| AI assistance for analysis and modelling |
First-release scope, with access being rolled out and further functions on the roadmap
|
Analyst, Modeler and Consolidation agents; the Planner Agent was marked as coming soon
|
The twelve areas CFOs and FP&A teams raise most often. Pigment capabilities are based on publicly available product information and documentation reviewed in October 2026.
Ownership means being able to do the work your team expects to manage after implementation, from changing forecast assumptions to administering access and data processes.
MODLR provides tools for trained finance and business users to manage planning models and processes, according to their permissions and the solution designed for their business.
As with any platform, model complexity, previous experience and governance requirements affect the skills needed.
Building and changing models in Pigment requires the appropriate permissions and an understanding of its modelling tools and formulas.
A finance-led operating model can still call for IT, vendor or partner support for particular tasks.
The practical difference
Assess three kinds of usability separately in each platform: contributors entering assumptions, builders making model and report changes, and administrators maintaining permissions and processes.
The buyer question is: which platform can our team understand, own and adapt after the implementation team leaves?
Both support multidimensional modelling, but they organise model data and calculations differently.
MODLR uses multidimensional cubes to organise data by entity, product, customer, department, scenario and time. Cube formulas connect calculations within and between cubes, and Workviews and Cards use the data for planning and reporting.
Visual tools also help prepare, transform and load data into these models.
Pigment builds models from connected Blocks: Dimension Lists, Transaction Lists, Metrics and Tables. Lists organise data by categories such as product, department, employee and time, Metrics hold inputs, calculations and results, and Tables bring related Metrics together for analysis and reporting.
Formulas connect these components to group, allocate and filter data across categories.
The practical difference
Both support models that analyse information across several business dimensions. The more useful questions are how easily your team can build, understand, maintain and adapt the model as requirements change, and who will own that work.
Ask each vendor to demonstrate the same change, such as adding a product category, revising a workforce assumption or introducing a new profitability view.
An implementation proposal should specify scope, responsibilities, dependencies, acceptance criteria and handover arrangements. That applies to both platforms.
Delivery scope, timetable, responsibilities and costs for MODLR are also established through a tailored proposal.
The same phased approach applies: a defined first phase, with later phases connecting to it.
Delivery scope, timetable, responsibilities and costs for Pigment are established through a tailored proposal.
A phased approach can be proposed: ask what the first phase would deliver, what would be deferred and how later phases connect.
The practical difference
Give both vendors the same brief, including data sources, historical periods, models, reports, workflows, users and controls. Comparing a focused first use case with a broader deployment will not give a meaningful result.
Time to go-live is when the agreed solution is available for use. Time to value is when an agreed, measurable benefit is achieved, such as completing a forecast cycle with less reconciliation work. Agree how the benefit will be measured in advance.
Both support forecasting and scenario planning, letting teams test assumptions and see how business changes could affect financial results.
MODLR supports scenario planning and what-if analysis through connected financial and operational models. A Scenario dimension can hold actuals, budgets, forecasts and alternative assumptions, and forecasts can combine actuals for completed periods with calculated values for future periods.
Ask MODLR to show how assumptions are changed, scenarios compared and movements explained.
Pigment uses Versions to organise planning cycles such as budgets and forecasts, and Scenarios to test alternative assumptions. Users can compare scenarios within Boards and Views.
Ask Pigment to show how scenarios work alongside forecast versions and how a baseline is preserved for comparison.
The practical difference
Ask both vendors to run the same scenario: sales volume falls by 15%, prices stay unchanged, and management considers delaying selected hires. Specify the outputs you need, such as revenue, gross profit, workforce costs and cash flow.
Check whether users can keep the baseline, document changed assumptions, compare periods and business units, trace a movement to its drivers, control who can edit and approve, and see which outputs update and which need more modelling. This is an evaluation exercise, not evidence that either platform has delivered a particular result.
Both provide tools for presenting planning information and investigating results. Assess how each connects summary reports with the detail needed to explain performance.
MODLR provides Workviews for detailed model reporting and analysis, alongside Cards for dashboards and interactive interfaces.
Ask how the proposed management reporting solution lets users move from a summary figure to the relevant data and calculations, within their permissions.
Pigment uses Boards to present grids, KPIs, charts and other widgets, configured for different audiences and reporting needs.
Users can expand views and investigate the data behind calculations. The detail available depends on the model, the tools configured and the user’s permissions.
The practical difference
Take a CFO who notices that forecast gross margin has fallen. In Pigment the investigation could start with a Board and continue through the relevant views and calculation inputs. In MODLR it could start with a Card and continue through a Workview showing the supporting model detail.
Request the same analysis from both, such as margin by product, customer, region or channel with changes in price, volume and cost. That analysis needs the relevant data and relationships to be in the model.
Both provide tools for bringing source data into the planning environment. The method, preparation work and ongoing maintenance depend on your systems and the proposed solution.
MODLR provides integration options across accounting, ERP, CRM, HR, databases, office applications and other business systems, including Xero, Salesforce, Microsoft SQL Server, SAP HANA and Google BigQuery, plus Excel and Google Sheets.
The Visual Process Editor and Visual Scripting Engine provide building blocks for database queries, API requests, files, transformations and model updates, combined into workflows that prepare and load data. The Excel Add-in retrieves model data and submits authorised planning inputs.
Pigment documents connectors and integration options for accounting, ERP, CRM, HR, data platforms and file storage, including SAP, NetSuite, Sage Intacct, Salesforce, Snowflake, Google BigQuery and SFTP.
It supports scheduled imports, import and export APIs, and connections through third-party integration tools. The Pigment Connector for Excel retrieves data from Pigment views and sends spreadsheet data into the platform.
The practical difference
A connector being available does not mean the integration will meet your planning needs. Compare the whole data process: how data is prepared, mapped, checked, loaded and maintained, who maintains it, and what happens when a source structure changes.
Ask both vendors to load monthly actuals, map accounts and departments, check totals and release validated data for reporting, including an exception such as an unfamiliar account code or a failed connection.
Both support automation within financial and operational planning. The processes covered depend on the features included and how the solution is configured.
MODLR’s Visual Process Editor lets users connect visual building blocks to create processes that import and transform data, run database queries and API calls, read, write and move files, update cube data, dimensions and hierarchies, send emails, and handle errors and process logs.
The editor combines visual steps with options for custom processes and formulas. The skills and support required depend on the complexity of the process.
Pigment supports scheduled data imports through connectors and eligible internal import configurations. Its Automations feature uses conditions in Metrics, such as a budget variance exceeding a threshold or a submission becoming ready for review, to trigger notifications or assign tasks.
Tasks can be linked into a sequence, with owners, due dates, progress monitoring and reminders. Linked workflows are available for Enterprise customers, so confirm they are in the package proposed for your business.
The practical difference
Ask both vendors to demonstrate the same process: import actuals, check the data, update a forecast and notify the person responsible for review.
Then ask which steps are automated and which need user action, how failures are identified and resolved, how plans are submitted, approved, returned or locked, who maintains the processes, and which features need extra licences, services or tools.
Both offer AI capabilities for working with planning data and models. These are evolving quickly, so assess the exact functions available to you at the time of evaluation and separate them from features awaiting release.
MODLR AI’s first-release scope covers plain-language questions about live model data, exploration of cubes, dimensions and hierarchies, assistance with scriptable processes, and Workview creation and editing. Access is being rolled out, with a waitlist in place.
As of 4 October 2026, generating Cards and charts, editing dimensions and hierarchies through AI, creating and explaining visual processes through AI, and creating structured models from uploaded attachments remain on the roadmap.
Pigment AI includes agents for different activities. The Analyst Agent supports exploring metrics, identifying trends and anomalies, and producing reports. The Modeler Agent assists with model creation and changes through natural-language instructions. The Consolidation Agent assists with accounting questions, reconciliation issues and consolidation controls.
Access depends on the features and permissions enabled for users. At the time of review (4 October 2026) the Planner Agent, for scenario simulation and recommendations, was marked as coming soon.
The practical difference
Give both vendors the same tasks and assess the results. Ask which functions your users can access today, which are in preview, on a waitlist or planned, what data the AI can see, how permissions apply, and what usage limits, charges and data-processing terms apply.
AI-generated explanations and model changes need appropriate review. Access to planning data does not, by itself, guarantee an accurate answer or a correct action.
Both provide controls for managing access to planning information. Assess how they would work for your sensitive data, model changes and approvals.
MODLR provides user-management and security controls for managing access and responsibilities. You can define who can enter data, maintain calculations, manage access and approve results.
Its Financial Close and Consolidation solution adds validation rules, financial controls and audit reporting for investigating changes. Confirm which controls apply to the models and processes in your proposal.
Pigment separates permissions from data-access rights. Permissions determine the actions users can perform, while access rights determine the data they can read or change. Roles combine these settings for different responsibilities.
Separate permissions govern configuring imports, viewing model history, changing Boards and accessing AI agents. Certain sensitive permissions can expose otherwise restricted data and should only go to people with authority to see that information.
The practical difference
Use the same access scenarios and audit requirements for both. Can salary and customer data be protected, and which administrative permissions could override those restrictions? Which data, formula and configuration changes are recorded, for how long, and can the records be exported?
Get confirmation of controls, configuration and commercial scope in writing.
Financial close involves checking, reconciling and finalising accounts for a period. Consolidation brings multiple entities into group statements after currency conversion, intercompany eliminations and adjustments. Both platforms offer solutions in this area.
MODLR’s Financial Close and Consolidation solution supports data loading, reconciliation, validation, audit reporting and foreign exchange analysis. Validation checks before and after loading help identify data quality issues, and audit trails record changes to data and model structures.
Consolidation includes multi-currency processing, intercompany matching and eliminations, journal methods and consolidated reporting. Rule-based processing is configured to reflect your entities, accounts and consolidation requirements.
Pigment’s financial consolidation supports multi-entity and multi-currency consolidation, intercompany matching and eliminations, journal entries and adjustments, consolidated financial statements, ownership structures and changes in which entities are consolidated.
Close and reporting workflows help coordinate activities, and audit trails and controls support review. Starter kits cover several accounting frameworks, including IFRS and US GAAP, and consolidated actuals connect with planning and analysis.
The practical difference
Do not assume a consolidation offering covers every statutory obligation. Prepare the same test cases for each vendor, with representative entities, currencies, ownership arrangements, intercompany balances and adjustments.
Ask how journals are reviewed and traced, how consolidated results reconcile to entity submissions, what happens when an adjustment is made after close, and what is supplied versus configured versus charged as extra services.
Scalability is the ability to handle more data, users, calculations and planning activity with acceptable performance, while keeping models, controls and administration manageable as requirements grow.
MODLR gives each customer a separate single-tenant cloud instance, with computing capacity that can be increased or reduced as needed. Capacity planning therefore includes the size and number of instances for the proposed workload.
Ask how additional data, users and processes would affect model design, resources and cost, and whether expansion needs more capacity, configuration changes or redesign.
Pigment uses multidimensional planning applications and its Graphite processing architecture. Its elastic engine adjusts computing resources during periods of higher demand, and parallel processing supports concurrent activity.
Ask how this would handle your data volumes, calculations, users and refresh cycles, and confirm applicable limits and commercial terms.
The practical difference
Both support financial and operational modelling across business dimensions, and in either platform performance depends on the models, calculations, data flows and workload. Their capacity approaches differ, resizable customer-specific instances versus an elastic processing engine, but that does not mean either will be faster or cheaper.
Use the same workload and growth assumptions for both, and test peak budgeting and forecasting periods.
Compare current written proposals that cover equivalent requirements, rather than inferring costs from vendor statements and positioning.
For MODLR, confirm the user roles, applications and computing capacity covered by the licence, and which features and environments are included.
Identify excluded work, how changes to agreed scope are charged, and what ongoing model ownership and administration will need.
For Pigment, confirm which features and environments are included in the subscription and which carry separate charges, including AI functions and any Enterprise-only workflow features.
Include integration tools, internal effort, training, support and growth costs on the same basis as for any other vendor.
The practical difference
Prepare a three-to-five-year cost model for each vendor covering subscription, implementation, integration, internal effort, training, support, growth, AI, and contract and exit costs. Use the same currency, contract period and assumptions about users, data volumes and scope.
Separate one-off costs from recurring charges, and confirm how changes to your assumptions would affect the total.
Both platforms support financial and operational planning. Use these considerations to build your shortlist, then assess each proposed solution against the same business requirements.
Take these to both vendors. The answers usually separate the two platforms faster than a feature list does.
Both MODLR and Pigment offer financial and operational planning capabilities. The better fit for your organisation depends on how the proposed solution meets your specific requirements, who will maintain it and its total cost.
Base your choice on demonstrated capabilities and clear delivery commitments. Confirm that your team can operate and maintain the solution with the agreed levels of training and support, and within budget.
The questions finance teams ask most often when comparing MODLR and Pigment.
MODLR can be evaluated alongside Pigment for financial and operational planning. Suitability depends on your organisation and the specific applications, integrations, controls and commercial terms that you require.
This comparison does not establish an overall winner. Evaluate each proposed solution against the same business requirements, demonstration tasks and acceptance criteria.
MODLR uses cubes, dimensions and hierarchies. Pigment uses Lists, Metrics and Tables. Test how each structure supports your calculations, reporting and model maintenance.
That depends on the implemented model, assigned responsibilities, training and the skills users have. Ask your team to perform representative changes in each platform and note where support is needed.
Implementation time depends on the scope of the assignment, your data readiness and the availability of resources. Request delivery plans for the same scope from both MODLR and Pigment, with common assumptions on data readiness, internal availability and acceptance criteria.
The best way to establish affordability is to compare written proposals from both vendors using a three-to-five-year cost model covering subscriptions, delivery, internal effort, support and expansion.
Both MODLR and Pigment have financial consolidation offerings. Confirm the included functions, configuration and services needed for your accounting and reporting requirements.
MODLR has the Excel Add-in, while Pigment documents an Excel connector provided as an Office Add-in. Test your workbook requirements and confirm the supported functionality and access conditions for each platform.
Do not assume so, because AI capabilities continue to evolve. MODLR’s AI page includes a waitlist and roadmap items, and Pigment’s homepage marked its Planner Agent as coming soon at the review date.
Confirm the availability and commercial terms of each feature you need at the time of your evaluation.
Give both vendors the same baseline, assumption changes and required outputs. Assess how scenarios are created, compared, documented and governed, and whether the results reconcile with your expected model logic.
If you are comparing Pigment with other planning platforms, bring a representative planning or reporting requirement, your data sources, expected users and control requirements, and see how MODLR would address them.
Pigment capabilities described on this page are based primarily on publicly available Pigment product information and documentation at the time of writing. MODLR capabilities are based on MODLR product information and platform functionality. Product capabilities, packaging, pricing and implementation requirements change over time, so validate your specific requirements directly with each vendor before making a purchasing decision. MODLR and Pigment names and any associated trademarks belong to their respective owners. References to Pigment identify the platform being discussed and do not imply affiliation, sponsorship or endorsement.